- 1965: Billy McNeill
- 1967: Ronnie Simpson
- 1969: Bobby Murdoch
- 1973: George Connelly
- 1977: Danny McGrain
- 1983: Charlie Nicholas
- 1987: Brian McClair
- 1988: Paul McStay
- 1998: Craig Burley
- 1999: Henrik Larsson
- 2001: Henrik Larsson
- 2002: Paul Lambert
- 2004: Jackie McNamara
- 2005: John Hartson
- 2007: Shunsuke Nakamura
- 2009:Gary Caldwell
- 2011:Emilio Izaguirre
- 2012:Charlie Mulgrew
- 2014:Kris Commons
- 2015:Craig Gordon